Menu

Jane Hutcheon

broadcaster/journalist/author

02 Sep
2018

Are Guests Always Honest With Their Answers and What Do You Do if They Aren't? FAQ

Jane Hutcheon

Great question!  As in news, we aim for fairness, balance and accuracy in producing an interview show.

We are quite organic: we record each interview for approximately 30 minutes and edit it to fit a 28 minute program slot, which is usually 26 minutes of interview.  We may shorten answers because of time constraints or where the answer slows down the flow of the interview. 

If we detect something that's potentially defamatory we consult the legal team. Hopefully, if there's an issue that isn't factual, I question that during the recording. But, whether someone is honest is a tricky one because our interviews rely on the memory, recollection and also the point of view of a guest. 

Sometimes I may not agree with a guest's opinion, but it doesn't mean the opinion shouldn't be heard.  

In a recent interview, author Blanche D'Alpuget discussed her essay On Lust where she described being molested at age twelve, by a judge (now deceased) who was in his fifties.  She refused to see this as sexual abuse or  to see herself as a victim. 

This is from the program transcript:

Some viewers didn't like that.  They felt I should have challenged Blanche further (the exchange continued but I didn't hammer into her point about whether the relationship was sexual abuse or not).

I found what she said confronting, but I also accepted the point of view that she didn't regard herself as a victim. I don't think you can change someone's mind by bagdering them.  In fact, I wanted to understand the fear of her powerful and terrifying father. 

I hope this answers your question.  There will be FAQ's relating to this one coming up.

 

Share this post:

comments powered by Disqus

01 Sep
2018

What Delights You, Frustrates You, Motivates You About Interviewing? FAQ

Jane Hutcheon

What delights, frustrates and motivates you about interviewing?

When I first started One Plus One in July 2010, I wondered why people would want to subject themselves to some quite personal questions.  But you see, I really wanted to know the answers!  I found the more I challenged myself with braver questions, the more generous the guest’s response. 

I’ve said it before but it was veteran Channel Nine journalist Peter Harvey who I credit with first giving me ‘permission’ to ask deeper questions about his mortality.  Peter died of pancreatic cancer in 2013.  During our interview, he would finish a sentence, just before he finished a thought so that I would have to follow up with another question. 

I regard this as a gift he gave me. And since that time, I've been given it over and over again.

Some things that delight me about interviewing:

  • having my research challenged or improved
  • when the guest reveals a surprising nugget of information
  • unexpected emotion (me and/or the guest)
  • forgetting I am recording an interview in a TV studio

What frustrates me?

  • I can get tongue-tied.  I don’t have the gift of the gab.
  • After hundreds of interviews, I can’t predict what the audience will or won’t like
  • I’d like more (constructive) professional feedback
  • Many guests have had a poor start in life.  This saddens me.

What motivates me?

  • Discovering amazing people who have never been interviewed
  • Finding and sharing human vulnerability
  • Constanly learning about different pathways people use in their lives

Share this post:

Comment

30 Aug
2018

What Experiences Have Taught You the Greatest Lessons? FAQ

Jane Hutcheon

What experiences have taught you the greatest lessons? How did you learn what you know?

My decade as a foreign correspondent was the greatest gift of education I will ever receive.  On last count, I think I’ve reported from more than twenty countries, excluding Australia. 

When working for shows like Foreign Correspondent I often spent a day or two with the people I was reporting on. This gave me an insight into incredible lives so different from my own.  I glimpsed life in a Palestinian refugee camp, what is was like to be the family of a young Israeli soldier killed in conflict, what it was like to live in a cave in the centre of China. 

Being receptive to other points of view makes you less judgemental and helps you see the different sides to a story.

Reporting from Iraq after the U.S.-led invasion in 2003 was a defining experience.  I am not a particularly brave person.  In those first few months I saw a lot of death.  People even came up to me on the street to show me photographs of dead relatives (and I don’t mean when they were alive). I realised that many Iraqis were so traumatised, dead bodies were no longer shocking to them.  I didn't enjoy being in war zones, but they teach you about the basics of what matters, of what humanity is.

As a child growing up in Hong Kong where my Dad was a newspaper editor, I awaited the arrival of the daily news under the front door. 

The headlines fascinated me and I saw that bad stuff happens, no matter who you are.

We knew people who died when an apartment building near ours collapsed in heavy rain.  Refugees fleeing China were attacked by sharks while swimming to freedom, the squatter huts (inhabited by poor people because there wasn’t enough housing) frequently went up in flames. A policeman lost his hand while detonating a bomb.

So in short, the greatest lessons have come from travelling widely and being curious.

Share this post:

Comment

30 Aug
2018

What's the Most Important Interviewing Skill? FAQ

Jane Hutcheon

What's the Most Important Interviewing Skill

That’s easy: it’s listening.

As a young reporter, I stubbornly stuck to the questions in my notebook, I rarely listened to what was said to me before I opened my mouth.

I think many broadcasters fear silence. Silence is a sign that something has broken down. Now I use my questions - which are printed out and attached to my beloved clipboard - as a guide only. 

Sometimes I barely refer to the questions.

If I’m caught in the moment of the guest's story, I think I’ve done my job well. 

If you like a particular style of interview, read/listen or watch a lot of them.

I’m drawn to interviews that are a bit like mine; I like to feel I’m taken below the surface chat. I think a good political interviewer is someone who systematically works his/her way into a problematic issue which they’ve found by carefully circling their prey subject.

Share this post:

Comment

16 Aug
2018

By Chance Life Books

Jane Hutcheon

I recently went to the 2018 Byron Writers Festival as a guest moderator.  I planned to use my downtime to write.  A children’s novel.  Very early stages.

The hotel had a resident dragon to keep us entertained and two of my favourite things for breakfast: sourdough bread and peanut butter.

 

 

 

 

 

 

But something in me shifted.  Maybe it was the magnificence of the lighthouse.  Or the encouraging warmth of the air.  Something was telling me NOT to shut myself in a room and tap away on a laptop.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It wasn’t the time to be a hermit.  I was meant to connect with other people and take in their wisdom.  This was no time to hide. 

Here are some of my Byron encounters:

Selina had the best job title of anyone: New Zealand Poet Laureate.  We talked about finding time to write.  She talked of gifts, or objects that tell us stories.  She left me with ideas and two recommendations:


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I met another poet.  His name is Lemn Sissay and he took my breath away performing his razor-sharp poem Hanging On, to an audience under the marquee.  I like the way he pronounces the 'g' in the middle of 'hanging'.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Alas, I didn’t write my novel, but I met 97 year old Nina who’s a One Plus One fan… she told me that if there’s a stem of roses covered in thorns, she only ever sees the roses. ​I’m glad I listened to the universe. 

Share this post:

Comment